Edinburgh International Festival - Edinburgh
29 April 2017

Company search

Country Company
click here for more photos for
this opera company
there are no videos for this
opera company

You've been granted free access to this page.

Take a FREE 7 DAY TRIAL or SUBSCRIBE today to access the full content of theoperacritic.com.

Free access

Performance reviews

Key Photo gallery Production details Video link
Così fan tutte

Edinburgh International Festival


No. of reviews: 9

Performances were strong across the board
30 Aug 16 / The Arts Desk
This production is uncomfortable and often unpleasant to watch
28 Aug 16 / The Herald
EIF’s Così fan tutte explores the opera’s darker side in an unsettling sexual manner
27 Aug 16 / Seen and Heard
Grown-up and intelligent
27 Aug 16 / The Opera Critic
Mozart's frothy opera turns nasty
27 Aug 16 / The Guardian
Points made, but underlined in red: a superbly performed Edinburgh Così fan tutte – for adults
27 Aug 16 / Bachtrack
This staging of Così fan tutte is a scandal – but not because of the nudity
27 Aug 16 / Telegraph
Racial and sexual abuse should shock audiences, not the titillation
27 Aug 16 / The Conversation
Brutal, challenging production that uses a sublime account of Mozart's music to nail home its point
26 Aug 16 / The Stage
Another fight at the opera in Cosi Fan Tutte row over wages
The South African production of Mozart’s masterpiece Cosi Fan Tutte ran into further trouble when it transferred to France.
Edinburgh Festival offers refunds before ‘extreme’ opera opens
The Edinburgh International Festival has taken the unprecedented step of offering refunds for one of its flagship operas before it is even staged in the city due to its extreme content.
Das Rheingold

Edinburgh International Festival


No. of reviews: 5

Valery Gergiev dirige L'Or du Rhin au Festival International d'Edimbourg
18 Aug 16 / Opera Online
A concert Rheingold full of emotional flow
18 Aug 16 / The Opera Critic
A powerful, authoritative performance that never flagged throughout its intimidating duration
17 Aug 16 / The Herald
Das Rheingold with a Russian flavour from Gergiev and Mariinsky Opera
17 Aug 16 / Seen and Heard
Mariinsky Rheingold a promising start to Edinburgh Festival’s concert Ring
17 Aug 16 / Bachtrack
Norma

Edinburgh International Festival


No. of reviews: 6

"Hell hath no fury": Cecilia Bartoli in Norma at the Edinburgh International Festival
8 Aug 16 / Bachtrack
Bartoli's emotional Norma
8 Aug 16 / The Opera Critic
The fiery Italian mezzo owned the stage as Bellini’s vengeful priestess
8 Aug 16 / The Guardian
It was a close-run thing - but Cecilia Bartoli's Norma is a furious triumph
7 Aug 16 / Telegraph
Dramatically strong
7 Aug 16 / The Stage
Triumph for classic opera with an anti-fascist twist
7 Aug 16 / The Herald
Edinburgh International Festival reveals first 2016 production
The Salzburg Festival's production of Bellini's Norma will open the opera section, with Cecilia Bartoli in the title role.
Die Zauberflöte

Edinburgh International Festival


No. of reviews: 9

The Magic Flute has never made more cartoonish sense
3 Sep 15 / The Spectator
Barrie Kosky and Suzanne Andrade’s production will have you rolling in the aisles
1 Sep 15 / WOW247
Lost in animation
31 Aug 15 / The Opera Critic
The Magic Flute pays homage to the era of silent films
31 Aug 15 / Seen and Heard
All the makings of a classic
29 Aug 15 / The Guardian
A "non-stop visual treat to accompany Mozart's strange fairytale"
29 Aug 15 / What's on Stage
Komische Oper’s Die Zauberflöte enchants at the Edinburgh Festival
29 Aug 15 / Bachtrack
The Magic Flute as silent movie, marrying many styles and eras with masterfully delivered music
29 Aug 15 / The Stage
Cute, but never sublime
29 Aug 15 / Telegraph
Barrie Kosky
'When I first saw The Magic Flute, I didn't get it and I didn't like it'
HMS Pinafore

Edinburgh International Festival


No. of reviews: 4

The audience was clearly enthralled throughout
25 Aug 15 / Edinburgh Guide
Starry casting in Edinburgh’s HMS Pinafore
25 Aug 15 / Seen and Heard
Joyless, stifled and stilted
25 Aug 15 / The Guardian
Having fun at the Festival
24 Aug 15 / The Opera Critic
Le nozze di Figaro

Edinburgh International Festival


No. of reviews: 6

The pace, ease and fun of the evening was contagious
25 Aug 15 / Edinburgh Guide
Even the best Stravinsky can’t beat mediocre Mozart
20 Aug 15 / The Spectator
Top-rank singers bring emotional power to Mozart’s Figaro
19 Aug 15 / Seen and Heard
A high energy Figaro
17 Aug 15 / The Opera Critic
Fischer's innovative take on Mozart
15 Aug 15 / The Guardian
Without heart
15 Aug 15 / Telegraph
The Rake's Progress

Edinburgh International Festival


No. of reviews: 6

Even the best Stravinsky can’t beat mediocre Mozart
20 Aug 15 / The Spectator
A performance that enchanted from start to finish
18 Aug 15 / WOW247
A joyous Rake's Progress
17 Aug 15 / The Opera Critic
Concert performance of The Rake’s Progress feels operatic
17 Aug 15 / Seen and Heard
Too good to be true: A very fine Rakes Progress at the Edinburgh International Festival
15 Aug 15 / Bachtrack
A rare, tender Stravinsky staging
14 Aug 15 / The Guardian
The Last Hotel

Edinburgh International Festival


No. of reviews: 7

Seedy menace
14 Aug 15 / Telegraph
Darkly compelling examination of suicide and loneliness
12 Aug 15 / The Stage
New Dennehy/Walsh opera tackles assisted suicide
12 Aug 15 / Seen and Heard
A searingly powerful new chamber opera
12 Aug 15 / The Guardian
World première of The Last Hotel at the Edinburgh Festival
12 Aug 15 / Bachtrack
A new opera from Enda Walsh proves a coup for the EIF
11 Aug 15 / What's on Stage
Thoughtful and life enhancing
10 Aug 15 / The Opera Critic
Les Troyens

Edinburgh International Festival


No. of reviews: 7

Mariinsky Opera's Yannis Kokkos delivers a stylised Berlioz production
2 Sep 14 / The List
The production for the Mariinsky Opera lacks cohesion, but the orchestral playing is magnificent
1 Sep 14 / Financial Times (via Google)
Russians bearing gifts: Mariinsky Opera brings Les Troyens to the Edinburgh Festival
30 Aug 14 / Bachtrack
A tale of two cities, and two women
30 Aug 14 / The Opera Critic
A rough-and-ready performance of Berlioz's neoclassical epic fails to stir
30 Aug 14 / Telegraph
Mariinsky without the magic
30 Aug 14 / The Guardian
Russian stars bring rich operatic highlight to last week of Edinburgh Festival
29 Aug 14 / The Arts Desk
Guillaume Tell

Edinburgh International Festival


No. of reviews: 4

A pin-sharp performance
29 Aug 14 / The Opera Critic
William Tell brims with a palpable sense of relevance
29 Aug 14 / Bachtrack
Hugely enjoyable
28 Aug 14 / Telegraph
Noseda does justice to Rossini's freedom fighter
28 Aug 14 / The Guardian
Owen Wingrave

Edinburgh International Festival


No. of reviews: 3

Crack team perform Owen Wingrave
18 Aug 14 / Seen and Heard
Neil Bartlett's production of Britten's opera is timely and moving
18 Aug 14 / What's on Stage
Bringing out the universality of Owen Wingrave
18 Aug 14 / The Opera Critic
American Lulu

Edinburgh International Festival


No. of reviews: 9

A tedious and pointless production, saved by the singing
4 Sep 13 / Opera Britannia
Olga Neuwirth’s new interpretation of Alban Berg’s unfinished Lulu failed on every count
3 Sep 13 / Independent
Olga Neuwirth’s new staging of Alban Berg’s masterwork is neutered and confused
3 Sep 13 / Financial Times (via Google)
Short of convincing
3 Sep 13 / Edinburgh Festival Guide
The material does nothing to endear its audience
3 Sep 13 / The Stage
Olga Neuwirth's misfiring reinterpretation of Alban Berg's unfinished opera is little improved by this new production
2 Sep 13 / The Guardian
A hypocritical exercise
2 Sep 13 / The Opera Critic
This update turns Lulu from an inexplicable force of nature to just another product of politics
2 Sep 13 / Telegraph
Olga Neuwirth's reinterpretation of Alban Berg's opera Lulu must be judged a fairly comprehensive failure
2 Sep 13 / The Herald
Alban Berg's Lulu turns freedom fighter
Lulu is one of opera's most astonishing characters, a femme fatale who manipulates and murders her way to a terrible end. Now she's been turned into a black American freedom fighter, singing to a jazz score.
Duke Bluebeard's Castle

Edinburgh International Festival


No. of reviews: 9

It's been a tough week for the women of opera
2 Sep 13 / Independent
A lavish Dido and an austere Bluebeard
28 Aug 13 / The Herald
Frankfurt Opera drew out the connections between these two apparently disparate works
28 Aug 13 / Financial Times (via Google)
Complexity is created through simplicity in both of Oper Frankfurt’s shimmering offerings
28 Aug 13 / The Stage
Unconventional pairing, but an enthralling double bill
28 Aug 13 / Opera Britannia
An emotion-packed performance
27 Aug 13 / Edinburgh Guide
Odd pairing of Purcell and Bartók operas
27 Aug 13 / Seen and Heard
Unusual bedfellows
26 Aug 13 / The Opera Critic
Frankfurt Opera's stylish and astutely directed double bill succeeds in shining new light on both Bartók and Purcell
26 Aug 13 / The Guardian
Dido and Aeneas

Edinburgh International Festival


No. of reviews: 9

It's been a tough week for the women of opera
2 Sep 13 / Independent
Complexity is created through simplicity in both of Oper Frankfurt’s shimmering offerings
28 Aug 13 / The Stage
Unconventional pairing, but an enthralling double bill
28 Aug 13 / Opera Britannia
A lavish Dido and an austere Bluebeard
28 Aug 13 / The Herald
Frankfurt Opera drew out the connections between these two apparently disparate works
28 Aug 13 / Financial Times (via Google)
Purcell’s best known opera was given a radical new twist
27 Aug 13 / Edinburgh Guide
Odd pairing of Purcell and Bartók operas
27 Aug 13 / Seen and Heard
Frankfurt Opera's stylish and astutely directed double bill succeeds in shining new light on both Bartók and Purcell
26 Aug 13 / The Guardian
Unusual bedfellows
26 Aug 13 / The Opera Critic
Fidelio

Edinburgh International Festival


No. of reviews: 8

The concept itself was doomed from take off
15 Aug 13 / Opera Britannia
A worthy musical performance compromised by a dog’s breakfast production
14 Aug 13 / Seen and Heard
Futuristic space travel and the Napoleonic era jostle uncomfortably in conceptual production from Lyon
14 Aug 13 / The Arts Desk
Fidelio, but not as we know it
13 Aug 13 / The Opera Critic
The obvious question about Opera de Lyon’s production is what are the effects like?
13 Aug 13 / The Stage
The production was saved from complete disaster by the music and the singing
13 Aug 13 / Edinburgh Guide
There were boos, there were hisse
12 Aug 13 / The Herald
Gary Hill's intervention robs Beethoven's masterpiece of its essential humanity
12 Aug 13 / The Guardian
Kazushi Ono
Edinburgh Festival 2013: Kazushi Ono, conductor of the opera Fidelio, talks to Hugo Shirley.
King Arthur

Edinburgh International Festival


No. of reviews: 2

A highlight of this year’s Festival
30 Aug 12 / Edinburgh Guide
The trio of principal soloists was very stylish
29 Aug 12 / Seen and Heard
Tristan und Isolde

Edinburgh International Festival


No. of reviews: 4

An emotion-packed production
28 Aug 12 / Edinburgh Guide
Jennifer Wilson thrills as Isolde
20 Aug 12 / The Opera Critic
Welsh National Opera translates its experience of the theatre to the concert platform
19 Aug 12 / Financial Times (via Google)
Shimmering orchestral playing in WNO’s Tristan und Isolde
17 Aug 12 / Seen and Heard
Vec Makropulos

Edinburgh International Festival


No. of reviews: 11

Ylva Kihlberg delivered a fuller, more emotive voice as the plot developed
28 Aug 12 / Edinburgh Guide
A great musical account of Janácek’s penultimate opera
25 Aug 12 / Telegraph
The evening gradually became something more rather than less of the sum of its parts
21 Aug 12 / Opera Britannia
Opera North's production of Janacek's bristling comedy of ageing and identity is stylish, salty, sardonic
20 Aug 12 / Independent on Sunday
Ylva Kihlberg had a handsome stage presence and performed well
19 Aug 12 / The Observer
The Makropulos Case fails to catch fire
16 Aug 12 / The Opera Critic
Excellent account of Janáèek opera from Opera North
16 Aug 12 / Seen and Heard
A vibrant production to die for
14 Aug 12 / The Stage
The evening’s star is Richard Farnes
14 Aug 12 / Telegraph
Kihlberg is in many ways exceptionally fine
14 Aug 12 / The Guardian
Richard Farnes and his orchestra alone made this otherwise disappointing production worthwhile
13 Aug 12 / Financial Times (via Google)
'I used to wish I didn’t have to go on’
Swedish soprano Ylva Kihlberg, who appears in The Makropulos Case at Edinburgh Festival 2012, tells Claire Prentice how she had to overcome crushing nerves to make her British debut.
David et Jonathas

Edinburgh International Festival


No. of reviews: 4

William Christie brings the score dazzlingly to life
23 Aug 12 / The Guardian
Raw emotions in this superb David et Jonathas
23 Aug 12 / The Opera Critic
In many ways the most striking innovation of the evening comes in Paul Zoller’s set
22 Aug 12 / Telegraph
The business on stage did little to enhance the thrill and excitement of hearing Les Arts Florissants
21 Aug 12 / Opera Britannia
No more reviews
Edinburgh International Festival
Edinburgh
Reviews search
Use this search to find historical reviews in our database
Performance schedule
Turnage
5 to 6 Aug 2017
Wagner
6 Aug 2017
Mozart
9 to 12 Aug 2017
Britten
13 Aug 2017
Monteverdi
14 Aug 2017
Monteverdi
15 Aug 2017
Monteverdi
17 Aug 2017
Verdi
18 to 20 Aug 2017
Puccini
25 to 27 Aug 2017

News & Articles

EIF 2017 looks to a bright flowering of the human spirit
The Edinburgh International Festival has announced the biggest programme of opera the Festival has mounted in many years.
16 Mar 2017 / The Herald
Edinburgh festival 2011 to have an eastern flavour
Opera, ballet and classical music from China and other Asian countries will dominate next year's event, say organisers.
14 Nov 2010 / The Guardian
Edinburgh International Festival: this year's programme unveiled
The Scottish Enlightenment is the starting point for an opera-rich 2009 festival.
26 Mar 2009 / The Guardian
New Edinburgh director puts L'Orfeo centre stage
The new director of the Edinburgh International Festival yesterday promised a programme for this year ranging "from the deeply serious to the seriously fun."
29 Mar 2007 / The Guardian
Edinburgh Festival warns operagoers
Edinburgh Festival warns operagoers about Bieito's bloody production of Trovatore, which features a man being set on fire, torture, blood-splattered massacre and hints of necrophil
31 Jul 2004 / Andante (Syndicated)