In
the October of 1893, Debussy started to plan an opera on the contemporaneous
'prose drama' Pelléas et Mélisande by Maurice Maeterlinck. Debussy
completed the score two years later but the opera was not heard until
30 April 1902 - a delay partly caused by Debussy's perfection-seeking
revisions and negotiations with the Opéra-Comique in Paris.
In his search for a new kind of French opera, Debussy looked to Wagner
in his wish to write continuous music and in the use of leitmotifs,
but the colours, expression and harmonies of Debussy's writing is recognisably
'French'.
Debussy's operatic setting of Pelléas et Mélisande (a story
that also attracted Fauré, Schoenberg and Sibelius) is regarded as something
of a challenge - for performers, producers and listeners. Over five
acts and 150 minutes or so of music, Debussy's ability to sustain a
mostly slow pace is astonishing - through multifarious dynamic contrasts,
subtle changes of colour and shifting harmonies that constantly divert
the ear and paint pictures. Furthermore we find out all we need to know
about the characters and their circumstances through the orchestra.
When emotions become heated or violent, or when the oppressive atmosphere
is gladdened by a chink of light or a breeze, this is meticulously sounded
in the orchestra through brighter textures, quicker tempos or the use
of fortissimo.
The orchestra and the conductor are crucial to the success of Debussy's
version of Pelléas et Mélisande. In the current production hosted
by The Royal Opera (a co-production with the Salzburg Easter Festival)
Sir Simon Rattle is a deeply sympathetic and perceptive interpreter
of Debussy's discriminating yet revealing music. At this first night
the inaugural sound to be heard, when the lights had lowered and Rattle
was about to conduct, was the ringing of a mobile phone. Fortunately
this stopped before the first music was heard. A beautiful, veiled sound
emanated from the pit. We see the lone figure of Mélisande. She becomes
very nervous of Golaud, who is also lost in the woods, as he enquires
of her. Bit by bit they become closer. They marry and return to Golaud's
family castle, a lonely and inhospitable place occupied by Geneviève
(mother to Golaud and Pelléas), Arkel (the king), Yniold (Golaud's son)
- and, of course, Pelléas himself. He is Golaud's half-brother, someone
that Mélisande is unsure of, but their relationship grows, partly through
innocence and naivety. Golaud has his bloody revenge at the end of Act
IV when he stabs Pelléas to death - the violence all the more shocking
for the restraint shown elsewhere.
Debussy's opera is a study of the human condition, of relationships
and feelings. A difficult work to stage, though, given there is little
action beyond the revealing of the characters, their surroundings and
their emotions. Under the direction of Stanislas Nordey, the production
team has not tried to inflate anything nefarious to add 'entertainment'.
Lighting is deliberately gloomy, save when extra brightness matches
the text, and the stage is dominated by moveable gigantic tombstone-like
designs that open up like trophy cabinets to display various collections
of pertinent artifacts. In Act IV the stage is lit blood-red, a portent
for the murder of Pelléas with which the act climaxes. An insular, hermetic
world is well suggested. It is difficult to know what could be added.
Similar effects could be achieved by other means and one can imagine
different costumes for the castle inhabitants other than satin-white
and bejeweled uniforms that seem more suitable for space travel than
an earthly kingdom.