The Seven Deadly Sins by Opera North (photo: Clive Barda)
Login | Subscribers Area | Contact
operareviews
1 August 2010
Untitled Document
Stuart Skelton triumphs as Grimes in ENO's dramatic new production
by Colin Anderson
Britten: Peter Grimes
English National Opera
9 May 2009

Photo: Clive BardaThis is a great evening at the opera. It was an inspired first night, too, one that suggests this current run should be a huge success and that David Alden's new production will become a fixture in English National Opera's repertoire.

As ever, one can have doubts about the staging but there is more to admire and praise than to carp out. The first coup is the dramatic beginning - Peter Grimes bursts onto the stage to abruptly cease the audience's hubbub; there is then some chatter from the community that fills the coroner's room before Edward Gardner cues the orchestra. The use of tables, fisherman Grimes atop of them, suggests already his isolation from the rest of the villagers. The inquest is to determine how Grimes's apprentice died at sea.

There's not much sympathy for Grimes. This only comes from Ellen Orford and, to a certain extent, Captain Balstrode. Otherwise Grimes is rejected, reviled, he will be hunted down and, eventually, at Balstrode's behest, take his boat out to sea and sink it. Yes, Grimes strikes Ellen and a second apprentice dies (as seen here, this is caused by Grimes being distracted by the baying mob).

Of course, the story is well known, the opera an enduring success since its premiere at Sadler's Wells Opera (the precursor of ENO) in 1945. Peter Grimes has been audio-recorded several times (conducted by the composer, Colin Davis, twice, Richard Hickox and Bernard Haitink). I would urge Chandos, for all that it has the Hickox version in its catalogue but has recently added Edward Gardner to its roster of artists, to consider issuing BBC Radio 3's recording on CD (the performance of 21 May is being captured for broadcast on 11 July) for musically this is all very distinguished.

Many things stand out. One is the immaculate diction of chorus and soloists (with surtitles, too, every word should make itself audible) which makes Montagu Slater's libretto more telling than it can be (inspired of course by George Crabbe's poem The Borough). Then there is the vivid characterisations of the roles in terms of Alden's direction, sometimes overdone it must be said, but each person is distinctive - not least the compassion of Ellen Orford, finely revealed by Amanda Roocroft, and Gerald Finley conjures a Balstrode tellingly at one remove from the crowd.

Photo: Clive BardaAs for Stuart Skelton's Grimes, he is his own man vocally (leaning towards Vickers but tempered by Langridge, and without mimicking either). This is a Grimes whom one feels less pity for, Skelton alive to Grimes's erratic nature, his bluff determination, his despair and his regret; his looming madness is also very well caught (reminding of Tristan's hysteria). Skelton's realisation of 'Now the Great Bear and Pleiades' (Act I) is especially haunting.

The opening of Act II is particularly evocative as staged here, a blissful Sunday Morning, which makes Grimes's striking of Ellen all the more shocking; so too the drum-led lynch-mob that goes in search of Grimes. The front room-like pub of Auntie is less convincing, so too the sparseness of Grimes's hut which seems rather too orderly; the dance that takes place in Act III is rather unconvincing in its robotic movements; and other gestures are, to use the phrase, sexed-up. But it matters not because the staging is generally compelling and tells the story well, with good sets, costumes and lighting.

As well as the successes for Skelton, Roocroft and Finley, the other members of the cast are also stellar and include Rebecca de Pont Davies (Auntie), Felicity Palmer (Mrs Sedley) and Matthew Best (Swallow). It's also a triumph for Edward Gardner who conducts a deeply considered, very well prepared, intense and dramatically concentrated performance, the ENO Orchestra in superb form and finding details afresh in Britten's evocative scoring (the Four Sea Interludes and the Passacaglia bind the whole: from subtle if eerie atmosphere to tempestuous power, this is a comprehensive revealing of Britten's orchestral prowess).

There are nine performances in all, the last two (on May 28 & 30) featuring John Daszak as Grimes. Whether Daszak or Skelton: don't miss!

Photos: © Clive Barda
Text: © Colin Anderson
Operabase
Privacy Statement | Terms of Use | Contact Us | Site Map
© 2010 The Opera Critic, PO Box 99826, Newmarket, Auckland, New Zealand