Skip to main contentSkip to navigationSkip to navigation
rehearsing The Killing Flower by Sciarrino
Rehearsals for Sciarrino's The Killing Flower.
Rehearsals for Sciarrino's The Killing Flower.

Interview: Salvatore Sciarrino - 'My problem is I want to change the world'

This article is more than 10 years old
His stage works are performed and acclaimed throughout Europe, but this week's Buxton opera festival production is a UK first. Salvatore Sciarrino talks to Andrew Clements about how, and why, he composes

Conversations with Salvatore Sciarrino can be wonderfully discursive. We meet to talk first and foremost about his opera Luci Mie Traditrici, which Music Theatre Wales is about to stage for the first time in the UK under the English title (suggested by Sciarrino himself), The Killing Flower. Our discussion, however, ranges from Tibetan thangas, to why the British in particular are so fascinated by the paintings of Piero della Francesca, and from the pet sparrow that he had as a boy in Sicily, to the birds that breed in the Po delta.

Now 66, Sciarrino is firmly established as one of the leading European composers of our time. His music inhabits an instantly recognisable soundworld of fragile, fleeting events that are often teetering on the edge of inaudibility, pushing instruments to the limits of their ranges and pitching voices into ambiguous territory somewhere between song and whispered speech. He has composed some 14 music-theatre pieces to date, of which Luci Mie Traditrici has become the most successful - one of the most widely performed European operas of recent times with three versions on disc as well as another on DVD.

But Michael McCarthy's production for MTW will not only be the work's British premiere, but the first time any of Sciarrino's operas has been presented here – over the last decade and more, it seems, his work has been yet another victim of British companies' almost systematic neglect of European music theatre.

But then Sciarrino is not, I sense, someone who is very comfortable at self-promotion, or too concerned about working the new-music system. Though he taught there in the late 1970s, he visits Milan very rarely now. He spent the early part of his life in big cities, growing up in Palermo, Sicily, and studying in Rome before moving to Milan, but for the last 30 years he's lived in Città di Castello in Umbria.

Salvatore Sciarrino
'Composers must be free'... Salvatore Sciarrino

Settling in that small town, he says, was "the best thing I did in my life – I have an ideal atelier, with good air and the light; it's in the middle of the town, but it's molto tranquillo. It changed my music; when you're in Milan you have to follow the rhythm of the city."

The result has been an immense outpouring of works over the last three decades, taking in almost every musical genre. But relatively few of those have been written to order, for Sciarrino has remained very wary of accepting commissions, and of being trapped on the treadmill of having to complete works by a deadline. "I have seen fantastic young talents destroyed because they accepted all the commissions that they were offered," he says. "I can write 10 or 15 pieces in a year, but sometimes it may be just one or two. It's a problem; composers must be free, but we also need money. I am very lucky; I am able to live and the quality of my life is very high."

He often accepts a commission only after a work has been completed, and Luci Mie Traditrici – a literal translation would be "My betraying eyes", though Sciarrino says that doesn't convey the sense of erotic possession implied in the Italian, hence his choice of a completely different title for the English translation – was first performed at the Schwetzingen festival in 1998. The libretto is based upon the play Il Tradimento per l'Honore, which was first published in Rome in 1664.

It unfolds the gruesome story of an Italian count, called Il Malaspina in the opera, and his wife (La Malaspina), who entertain a mysterious and unnamed guest. The countess and the stranger make love, but a servant betrays them to the count, who forgives his wife for her infidelity before revealing the corpse of her lover and then killing her. It was originally thought to be the work of Giacinto Cicognini, who wrote one of the very first Italian plays based upon the Don Giovanni story and also produced very successful librettos for Cavalli and other Venetian composers in the 1640s, but since the opera was first performed it's been discovered that Cicognini was not its author at all, and that the play was attributed to him on publication simply to increase its sales.

When he'd first read the text, Sciarrino had been struck by the similarity of its plot to the story of the late renaissance composer Carlo Gesualdo, who famously murdered his wife and her lover in 1590. He'd originally intended to compose an opera specifically about that historical event, before discovering that Alfred Schnittke was just completing his own Gesualdo opera. He therefore made his own work much less specific, paring down the text, taking out "what feels like literature" to produce the extraordinary patchwork of half articulated, half implied exchanges that gives the 70-minute piece much of its powerfully mysterious charge.

rehearsing The Killing Flower by Sciarrino
Music Theatre Wales rehearsing The Killing Flower.

In the 1980s he'd devised a way of setting words by having them sung on a slow glissando that preserved the microtonal inflections of speaking. "When a singer speaks onstage, it's usually very embarrassing, but we must always find something that hasn't existed before. . . the problem is that we must represent the tragedy and not become the tragedy ourselves." Using such techniques he came up with something that was much more ambiguous, a dramatic framework that was far removed from opera as it had developed over the last three centuries. If Sciarrino's music theatre has antecedents at all, they are to be found right back in Monteverdi; he admits that seeing a performance of Il Coronazione di Poppea as a teenager left a deep impression.

His most recent opera, Superflumina, received its premiere three years ago, but ideas for at least two new ones are slowly maturing. "It's not difficult to find the subjects, I have many that I haven't tackled yet." But his ambitions go much further than that: "I want to find a new solution to music theatre; if we don't find one, we are dead and our culture is dead. Any kind of theatre now has to be conditioned by cinema, and by its way of editing. The composer is no longer at the centre of things, now the connections are made by the listener. But my problem really is that I want to change the world."

* The Killing Flower opens at Buxton Opera House (0845 127 2190) on 16 July, and tours to Cardiff, London, Llandudno and Swansea from 18 October.

Comments (…)

Sign in or create your Guardian account to join the discussion

Most viewed

Most viewed