Opera Reviews
6 May 2024
Untitled Document

Bayreuth at the forefront of Augmented Reality technology

by Tony Cooper

Wagner: Parsifal
Bayreuth Festival
August 2023

The flower maidens

The season opened with a ground-breaking new production of Parsifal directed by Jay Scheib, an American of international standing in the hi-tech world and a technological wizard. A couple of his credits include Thomas Adès’ Powder Her Face (New York City Opera) and the Jim Steinman/Meat Loaf musical, Bat Out of Hell (Capitol Theatre, Düsseldorf).

A professor of music and theatre arts at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Scheib is well known for his genre-defying works of daring physicality and the integration of new (and used) technologies in live performance. Therefore, in his realization of Parsifal for Bayreuth he has thrust this iconic festival into the digital age by engaging in Augmented Reality.

Annoyingly, though, those members of the Society of Friends of Bayreuth, headed by Georg von Waldenfels, are light years away from Scheib’s thinking and, indeed, from Katharina Wagner’s thinking and vision too. They harbour strong ideas of how Wagner’s operas should be presented and, therefore, with Scheib’s take on Parsifal it floundered a bit as far as they were concerned.

But such technology as Augmented Reality, an interactive experience that enhances the real world with computer-generated perceptual information, is a thought-provoking and bold move to engage in but, hopefully, such ideas as the likes that Scheib harbours will appeal and attract newcomers in anticipation of productions more in keeping with their viewpoint and in keeping, too, with modern-day theatrical presentation.

In essence, AR enables audiences to immerse themselves into a virtual three-dimensional world and, therefore, by using software, apps, hardware and the like, while employing the use of 3D glasses, technology overlays digital content on to real-life environments and objects in which the physically existing world is expanded by virtual content.

Turning the clock back, I well remember those crudely cardboard-made red-and-green 3D glasses that came into being in the pioneering years of three-dimensional viewing in the late 1950s. Come the 1970s and you’ll find Andy Warhol and Paul Morrissey had a go reviving the format for their movie, Flesh for Frankenstein. And now Bayreuth finds itself centre stage immersed in a simulated three-dimensional environment in what is one of the most ambitious attempts to incorporate AR into opera performance.

A free and futuristic thinker, Scheib came up with an amazing production of Parsifal that could be either enjoyed engaging in AR technology or simply sticking to a traditional staging. Just as well, really, as not every member of the Festspielhaus audience was equipped with 3D glasses owing to the high cost of providing them over the course of just seven performances. Therefore, with a seating capacity of 1,925, there was disappointment in many quarters because only 330 audience members or so were blessed in seeing the show as truly conceived by Scheib and his video/AR designer, Joshua Higgason.

A complicated process, the technology of Augmented Reality can only be viewed through headsets which are linked to small boxes under one’s seat not too dissimilar to smartphones without, of course, screens. Each box has an app containing the AR content directly linked to the glasses. A stage manager is on hand following the piano score communicating as to when the content should appear.

Further disappointment was caused when Joseph Calleja withdrew from the title-role due to a persistent throat infection. He was replaced by Andreas Schager who, in fact, made his Bayreuth debut in the same role in Uwe Eric Laufenberg’s magnificent staging of Parsifal in 2016. Originally, Schager had been scheduled to sing Erik in Holländer, that role passing on to Croatian tenor, Tomislav Mužek.

A memorable production for sure it will also be memorable for the Spanish conductor, Pablo Heras-Casado, making his Bayreuth debut. And what a debut! A baptism by fire! However, he soon got to grips with the acoustics of the Festspielhaus which can often be tricky for a newcomer but in my opinion he kept the right balance between the pit and the stage. Under his direction the orchestra excelled in the playing of the prelude - a slow, religious tone poem based on the motives of the love feast, the spear and the grail - which wraps up and sets the scene for the entire opera.

Through my 3D glasses I found myself wrapped up and entwined in an abundance of nature in Act I ranging from forest scenes galore to a wide canvas of floral patterns all floating heavenly round Bayreuth’s vast auditorium and, indeed, with specific images directed towards me. I was transported to another world, a fantasy world, really, one of make-believe, where wonder, amazement and surprise kept good company with the opera’s main themes.

Thoughts flashed through my mind how different my last 3D experience was in the fifties. It’s beyond comparison compared to the interactive experience this time round. For instance, in the scene in which the innocent youth Parsifal arrives at the Hall of the Holy Grail, the AR element to the production was second to none featuring oversized images of an entire flock of flying swans entering your visionary space and floating throughout the vast auditorium of the Festspielhaus to mesmerising effect.

Another good example of the AR content was at the moment when Klingsor hurls the holy spear at Parsifal who miraculously catches it in midair thus causing his realm to collapse. Immediately this scene was transported to the AR world by an extremely large floating image of the spear heading straight towards me. It was so close to me I felt I could touch it. After lingering awhile, it simply vanished into thin air. Unbelievably, individual images such as the spear can be directed straight to one’s seat.

Every so often I took my 3D glasses off just to concentrate on the stage aspect of the production until curiosity got the better of me. I felt I was missing out in the world of AR.

If AR wasn’t enough, a video technician, permanently on stage, transmitted his images directly to various screens darted around the stage so, overall, there was a lot of visual activity to take in.

If the production was strong in the floating world of augmented reality it was even stronger at ground level fielding a formidable team of strong Wagnerians such as Bayreuth favourite Andreas Schager and mezzo-soprano Ekaterina Gubanova storming the role of Kundry. How well this pair worked together.

The cast was further enriched by another favourite, Georg Zeppenfeld, as the veteran knight of the Holy Grail, Gurnemanz, while Derek Welton as Amfortas, king of the Grail, dramatically played his part to the full while Tobias Kehrer took the role of Titurel. And the one we all like to hate, the baddie of the pack, Klingsor, was played to the full by baritone Jordan Shanahan, making his Bayreuth debut. In a Svengalian and manipulative way he delivered a magical performance that more than highlighted his acting abilities which a packed house adorably lapped up.

The trio of creatives - Mimi Lien’s sets, Meentje Nielsen’s costumes and Rainer Casper’s lighting - fitted so well the production overall while the colourful (over-the-top) stage picture of the flower maidens’ scene looked like a clip from the Barbie movie that has taken the world by storm. As an aside, black tie is the norm at Bayreuth but a male member of the audience sitting directly in front of me could be said to be challenging the traditional dress code by sporting a Barbie T-shirt. At Bayreuth?

The setting for the last scene, in stark contrast to the nature-loving opening scene, was a rather drab-looking affair punctuated by a long-abandoned industrial vehicle dumped beside a dirty pond in a rubbishy down-trodden area with the AR content amass with a load of floating plastic bags and containers of all descriptions as well as industrial waste such as solid-state batteries and the like highlighting the wastefulness and the deterioration of society in general which in my thinking equated to the suffering and deterioration brought upon the knights of the Grail through Parsifal’s foolish ways.

But Parsifal redeems himself and the Brotherhood is saved. Abruptly, though, the ending came with Parsifal smashing the Holy Grail, seen as a piece of blue cobalt rock, to pieces. Once again, in the context of the production’s AR content, the overall stage effect of this ‘odd’ happening focused on an abundance of large chunks of rock floating aimlessly round the auditorium as if in outer space but in reality were floating before your very eyes.

Change comes slowly in many respects in life especially at Bayreuth and, therefore, I think it’s fair to say that Katharina Wagner and Jay Scheib’s gamble, if that’s the right word to use, paid off. However, gazing into my crystal-ball, I should dearly like to see a commissioned opera or, indeed, a musical, created especially with AR technology in mind staged in a new purpose-built theatre designed in a similar vein to the ABBA Arena at London’s Queen Elizabeth Olympic Park in Stratford East which is elevating the ABBA Voyage show to a different (and higher) level of entertainment never seen before.

What happens next at Bayreuth. I wonder? However, over the past few years one cannot deny that Katharina Wagner has attracted a host of enterprising and gifted directors to the festival who have conceived and delivered a string of stunning productions such as Barrie Kosky’s Meistersinger, Yuval Sharon’s Lohengrin and Tobias Kratzer’s Tannhäuser while Frank Castorf’s Ring hit the mark (especially for me) but overall got the thumbs down. Extraordinarily, it’s now being hailed as a worthy and progressive production by many Wagnerites I meet on my travels.

Interestingly, the Bayreuth Festival has been led by a member of the Wagner clan since the death of Richard Wagner in 1883 while Katharina Wagner, his great-granddaughter, took over the joint artistic directorship of the festival with her half-sister, Eva Wagner-Pasquier, from their father, Wolfgang, in 2008, while becoming sole artistic director in 2015. As her contract comes up for renewal soon, Katharina Wagner has firmly stated that if an offer came her way (and I sincerely hope it does) she would only accept the post on condition that changes are made to the festival’s organisation.

She also emphatically said: ‘You need to make Bayreuth fit for the future and if some structural things don’t change, then it will be impossible for me to carry out my work.’ She further added that ‘if Bayreuth just continues to mount traditional-style productions audiences might as well sit at home and watch Wagner on DVD’. There you have it!

Text © Tony Cooper
Photo © Bayreuther Festspiele / Enrico Nawrath
 
Support us by buying from amazon.com!